Episode #73 – The Cash Flow Conundrum: Why Your Law Firm Can Be Profitable on Paper but Struggling to Pay Bills

How does free CLE sound? Please join me at the Virtual Legal Seminar hosted by LawPay, MyCase, DocketWise and CASEpeer. I will be one of the speakers at this half-day virtual event. It’s being held on October 1st. Register HERE.

Today we're diving into a paradox that puzzles many law firm owners: how can your business show a healthy net income, yet struggle with cash flow?

The Profit vs. Cash Flow Disconnect

Let's start with a scenario many of you might relate to. Your latest P&L shows a respectable net income, but your bank account is running on fumes, and you're stressed about making payroll. How is this possible? The answer lies in understanding the difference between profitability and cash flow.

Common Cash Flow Problems in Law Firms

What’s causing your money problems? Simply put it’s the timing – money is slow to come into your firm but quick to leave. Here are some examples. 

Delayed Client Payments

Law firms historically have billed clients once a month for services rendered. This creates a scenario where the work you have completed in the first week of a month will not be paid for a minimum of 4 weeks, but realistically more like 5-6 weeks. And that’s if your billing is completed in the first week of the next month and your clients are fast to pay upon receipt.

Work in Progress (WIP)

Unbilled work represents future revenue, but you have current expenses.  You will have client costs to pay in advance to the extent that your clients have not provided a retainer for their case work. Plus, you're paying for your payroll costs now, but not receiving cash until later.

Operating Expenses

Rent, salaries, software subscriptions need to be paid regularly. These create a steady cash outflow, regardless of your cash inflow situation.

Owner & Partner Distributions

Distributions to the firm’s owners are not reported on your P&L. So, if you take $100 in distributions or $100,000, the net income on your P&L will not change. Be careful with distributions because if done without planning, they can deplete cash reserves and leave the firm cash-poor despite being profitable.

Firm Debt

Firm debt has a similar impact as owner & partner distributions. Let’s say you have a monthly loan payment of $1,000. That payment is really two things that you are paying. You are paying interest to the lender and paying back some of the principle. The interest piece will be reported on your P&L but the principle is reported on your balance sheet. 

Solutions to Bridge the Gap

Now that we’ve talked about what is creating these issues in your firm, let’s talk about how to better manage your cash flow.

Enhance Billing Practices

Increase the frequency of your billings process. Now, I know you won’t be able to bill contingent cases until they are settled – that’s a given. But for flat fee work require at least 50% of the bill be paid prior to the work being started with the balance due upon delivery. And for hourly work, – try billing every week or every other week instead of month. If this change makes you feel uncomfortable, I ask that you at least try it with this modification – perform the billing process every week but only for the matters that were closed last week. No matter what billing system you use, you can’t bill the same time ticket twice. 

And, a bonus here is when you bill weekly, you are forced to have all time tickets entered weekly. Capturing time tickets in real time will improve the accuracy in comparison to capturing time tickets and billing on a monthly basis.

Be sure to include a specific due date on your bill – do not use the phrase “due upon receipt” which can give an excuse to the client to wait to pay it.

Lastly, define your firm’s follow-up procedures for unpaid bills. What I mean here is to set up automated reminders for unpaid bills if your billing system has this feature. Have the billing system send a reminder every 7- 10 days. Be sure to include tasks such as phone calls and mailed letters the longer a bill goes unpaid. Unless the client is a one person operation, contact should be made to different people for a status on the payment.

Now this is something that I think established firms are good at but maybe a newer firm hasn’t thought of yet. Consider requiring retainers. For litigation, request retainers covering estimated fees for next 60-90 days. For transactional work: Set up milestone payments tied to specific deliverables.

Start accepting credit card payments from clients. I know traditionally, the legal industry has been entrenched in receiving checks from clients. Yes, accepting credit cards costs money, typically 3-5% of the transaction amount. But, if you use a processor that is integrated into your billing system, accepting credit card payments online will actually reduce the time needed to post payments to the client’s account. Raise your rates across the board by 5% to cover the merchant fees. Accepting credit cards will help you get paid faster. So, it will also alleviate time wasted on collecting on aging unpaid bills.

Manage Work in Progress

Regularly convert WIP to invoices. Implement bi-weekly WIP reviews to identify billable work. Require your staff to submit time entries daily.

Monitor and manage the growth of unbilled work. Set WIP thresholds for each matter; alert partners when those limits have been exceeded. Use visual dashboards to track WIP across the firm.

Cash Flow Forecasting

Develop a rolling 13-week cash flow forecast. Use historical data and known upcoming expenses to project cash needs. Update weekly, comparing projections to actuals to improve accuracy.

Use this to anticipate and prepare for cash crunches. Identify potential shortfalls 4-6 weeks in advance. Develop action plans for different scenarios (e.g., accelerate collections, defer expenses).

Credit Line Management

Establish a line of credit for working capital needs. Negotiate terms with multiple banks to find the best rates and conditions. Consider asset-based lending using accounts receivable as collateral.

Use it judiciously to smooth out cash flow fluctuations. Draw on the line to cover short-term gaps, not long-term deficits. Repay quickly when cash flow improves to minimize interest expenses. 

Align Partner Compensation

Tie partner draws more closely to cash collections, not just paper profits. Implement a base draw plus bonus structure based on collections. Use a "lock box" approach: allocate a percentage of collections to partner compensation.

Case Study: Smith & Jones Law Firm

Let’s see how taking an active role in managing your firm’s cash flow can look. Here’s a case study from a firm where I’ve changed the name for privacy reasons. We’ll call this firm Smith & Jones Law Firm.

Background:

• 2 partners and 3 associates

• Specializes in corporate, IP, and employment law 

• Annual revenue: $1.6 million

• Net income: $235,000

The Problem:

Despite showing a healthy profit, Smith & Jones found itself consistently short on cash. The partners were frustrated that their distributions were sporadic, and the amounts fluctuated, and the firm had to dip into its line of credit to make payroll several times throughout the year.

Root Causes:

• Delayed Payments: The firm's largest client which represented about 50% of the firm’s revenue consistently paid invoices 60-90 days after receipt.

• Work in Progress: Though not part of their wheelhouse, the firm had taken on some litigation cases which led to large WIP balances.

• Partner Draws: Monthly partner draws were based on projected annual profits, not actual cash collections.

Solution Implementation:

• Billing Practices: 

Negotiated new payment terms with their largest client, offering a 2% discount for payments within 30 days. Implemented milestone billing for litigation cases, with 25% due at filing, 50% due at discovery completion, and 25% due at trial or settlement.

• WIP Management:

Instituted bi-weekly WIP reviews for all cases over $25,000. Implemented a policy to bill at least 50% of WIP on large cases every other week.

• KPI Dashboard:

Brought me onboard as their Fractional CFO to develop and maintain their KPI dashboard. By focusing on specific numbers that aligned to their goals, they knew at one glance if they were on or off target to meeting their goals. We discussed monthly what changes were working so they knew to keep those in place and we worked to tweak what did not seem to be working to get them back on track.

• Cash Management System:

Implemented a cash management system that gave them a plan in advance with how to use all incoming money. It let them set aside small amounts of money every week towards known large expenditures (e.g., annual malpractice insurance premium, hiring a new associate in the future, year-end bonuses) so one large payment didn’t create panic.

• Partner Compensation:

Restructured partner compensation to include a base draw (50% of expected compensation) paid monthly, with quarterly distributions based on actual cash collections.

Results:

After six months of implementing these changes:

• The firm's average days sales outstanding decreased from 73 to 42 days.

• WIP balances decreased by 30%.

• The firm hasn't needed to use its line of credit for working capital in the past quarter.

• Partner satisfaction improved as distributions became more predictable and aligned with the firm's cash position.

This case study demonstrates how understanding and actively managing the relationship between profitability and cash flow can transform a law firm's financial health and operational stability.

Remember, profitability is important, but cash is king. By understanding the disconnect between net income and cash flow, and implementing strategies to bridge that gap, you can ensure your firm not only looks good on paper but also maintains the liquidity needed for smooth operations.

Are You A Law Firm Owner Looking To Boost Your Profits? 

You started your firm with the goal of making money, right? Well, let’s make sure you’re on the right track! Whether you’re just starting out or have been in the game for years, there’s always room for improvement.

Join the Your Profitable Law Firm Community! This community is designed to help you run your law firm more profitably. Now, we’re not reinventing the wheel here – these strategies have been tried and tested by thousands of law firms over decades. But what sets us apart? We break down these proven ideas into practical, actionable steps that you can implement right away.

Here’s how it works: Each month, we focus on one specific strategy. Think of it as a bite-sized approach to optimizing your business. These are the same types of strategies that high-priced management consultants would recommend – but without the hefty invoice! Plus, we’ll help you maximize revenue from each client and uncover the not-so-secret key to greater efficiency.

Imagine your law firm where profits flow effortlessly, where you’re getting the most out of your staff and technology. Whether you want a boutique lifestyle business or have dreams of scaling up, the choice is yours. So why wait? Let’s turn your law firm into a profit powerhouse! Click HERE to join the community today.

If you have any questions about today's episode please let me know by commenting below. If you know someone who might need to hear this information please share this episode with them. 

Be sure to follow and subscribe to get notifications for future episodes. 

Did you enjoy this episode? Please consider leaving a review. 

And before I go, remember profit is something you intentionally plan for in the beginning. It is not a potential bonus at the end of the year. 

Thanks, and have a great day.